North Main Street, Tonetta Lake Road, North Brewster Road
- Direction:
 - North/South
 - Southern Terminus:
 - Brewster village line
 - Northern Terminus:
 - NY 312 in Brewster
 - Distance:
 - 2.85 miles
 - Signed:
 - Yes
 
CR 58 is a north/south route through the area just north of the Village of Brewster. North Main Street splits off from US 6 as a local street within the village and then becomes CR 58 at the village line. It runs north for a short distance before curving to the east to become Tonetta Lake Road. It passes under I-84, but there is no interchange. After a short distance, it curves back to the north to become North Brewster Road. It ends at NY 312.
| Photo Gallery | 
|---|
| Map |